Toni Payne Stars as Everton Cruise Past West Brom in FA Cup Fourth Round

Nigeria international Toni Payne delivered a superb performance as Everton Women ran out comfortable 5–0 winners over West Bromwich Albion Women in the FA Cup Fourth Round on Friday, booking their place in the fifth round.

Payne was directly involved in two of Everton’s goals, starting the move that led to Yuka Momiki’s opener inside the first 10 minutes, and later scoring herself shortly after the break to seal the emphatic victory.

Momiki scored twice in the first half to put Everton firmly in control, with goals from Ornella Vignola, Payne and Issy Hobson completing the scoring in the second half as the Super League side dominated throughout.

Payne’s contribution an assist and a goal stood out as Everton asserted their quality against third-tier opposition, reinforcing their credentials as strong contenders in this season’s FA Cup.  With the convincing win, Everton now progress confidently into the fifth round draw, which is scheduled to take place later this week.

EDITORIAL

In the theatre of knockout football, where drama is prized and uncertainty reigns, Everton’s emphatic FA Cup victory over West Brom was a demonstration of supremacy rather than suspense. In Toni Payne’s performance one that blended creativity with clinical execution we saw not just a player in form, but a statement of intent from a club seeking momentum in a congested season.

Payne’s assist for Yuka Momiki’s early opener was textbook in its simplicity a deft pass that unlocked a retreating defence — and her goal shortly after the interval was the exclamation mark on a performance of composure and ambition. These moments mattered because they came at times when the tie could have stagnated instead, they propelled Everton into a commanding lead and underscored the gulf in levels on the night.

Yet beyond the statistics of goals and assists lies the subtler narrative of influence. A player’s worth in cup football is often measured not just by what she produces, but by how her presence shapes the rhythm of a team. Payne’s dynamism invited pressure on the flank, her movement created space for colleagues, and her confidence in possession communicated leadership in what was a polished collective performance.

In the broader canvas of the Women’s FA Cup, performances such as this help define not only progression to the next round but also the identity of a side capable of blending individual excellence with cohesive teamwork. Everton’s path forward will be tougher, no doubt the further one ventures, the narrower the margins — but if this display is any indication, they will carry both belief and impetus into the draw.

DID YOU KNOW?

1. Toni Payne has been a consistent creator for Everton this season, ranking among the squad’s top assist providers in all competitions.
2. Payne has made over 26 appearances for the Nigerian women’s national team, contributing experience at both club and international level.
3. Yuka Momiki’s brace in this match helped her continue a strong scoring run, highlighting her importance to Everton’s attack in cup competitions.
4. Everton’s FA Cup win over West Brom was one of the largest margins of victory in the Fourth Round ties this season, reflecting a dominant performance.
5. Progressing to the fifth round puts Everton into the final 16 of the FA Cup, with the next draw determining home and away fixtures.